Can Indoor Plants Reduce Air Pollution Cost-Effectively? An Economic Assessment of Natural Air Purification
Potted plants are encouraged as a low cost, nature-based solution to indoor air pollution, which is one of the most significant environmental health risks. However, the economic viability of phytoremediation has never been evaluated with respect to the physical capacity of leaf uptake of pollutants. This paper translates 196 published chamber measurements into clean air delivery rates (CADR) which are used to rate engineered air cleaners, and then into levelised costs of clean air and cost per disability-adjusted life year (DALY) avoided. A well-mixed mass-balance model is parameterised for a room of 30 m3, three occupants and a room air change rate of 1 air change per hour, a Dhka case being used as an example of a high exposure case. With the median single plant CADR of 0.023 m3 h−1, 1,304 plants are required to replace 1 ACH, at a cost of USD 42,652 annually, or 109 plants per square metre. The levelised cost is USD 0.162 per m3 of clean air, compared to USD 0.0000689 for HEPA filtration and USD 0.00052 for mechanical ventilation. Passive plants are inefficient in removing the fine particles, while the cost of plant-based PM2.5 abatement is approximately USD 9.4 million per DALY, which is less than 10% of the per capita GDP of Bangladesh. According to the break-even analysis, the potted plant would have to provide 54 m3 h−1 of clean air, which corresponds to some 2,357 times the measured performance, to outcompete filtration. Plants are thus biophilic design elements, not pollution control technology, and claims by regulators or companies that they are the same are not economically justifiable.
In industrialised countries and rapidly urbanising economies, people spend almost 90% of their time indoors and personal exposure to many pollutants is driven by the indoor environments in which time is spent. The Global Exposure Mortality Model estimates that ambient fine particulate matter (PM2.5) is responsible for 8.9 million premature deaths per year globally, and the Global Burden of Disease programme estimates about 4.2 million deaths per year due to ambient air pollution, with residential energy use, agriculture, power generation and traffic as the most important contributors to the attributable burden. Much of that exposure is through outdoor pollution that shows up inside the house, and also through volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and products of reaction with ozone and resuspended particles produced inside the house (Morawska et al., 2013; Weschler, 2006). Cooking emissions and a lack of ventilation exacerbate the situation in low and middle-income countries, with mean indoor PM2.5 ~5 times the World Health Organization 24-hour guideline, as measured in 43 households in Dhaka.
In this context, indoor plants have an unusual policy status. Credits are awarded in sustainability schemes for indoor greenery, corporate wellness programmes use green offices as proof of green commitment and the trade and popular media constantly write about potted plants as natural air purifiers. The claim is based on a report by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) that examined a few ornamental species in closed containers and found measurable depletion of formaldehyde, benzene and trichloroethylene. This study has been supported by a substantial experimental literature on species-specific uptake, on the relative contribution of foliage and root-zone substrate, on the influence of light, humidity and growing medium as well as field trials reporting lower VOC concentrations after plants were introduced.
The economic question is not the same as the question of the removal of pollutants by the plants. Removing a pollutant is not enough for a technology to be an efficient method of improving health, it must remove a large amount of a pollutant relative to alternatives per unit cost of removal. Source control for indoor air management consists of the use of low-emission materials, more outdoor-air ventilation and particle or sorbent filters with known costs and effectiveness. The BCRs for filtered water consistently fall between 4 and 130 when monetary values are assigned to the impact of mortality reduction; a comprehensive nationwide evaluation of portable purifiers has shown that the cost can be of the order of tens of thousands of yuan per DALY. For potted plants, no such evaluation has been undertaken; promotion of a low price for the product is based on the assumption that a near zero purchase price means a low per unit cost of pollution removal.
The physics of leaf mediated uptake is what that means, and it is a constraint that price cannot do without. Cummings and Waring (2020) converted 196 chamber measurements across 12 studies to the air-cleaner industry metric of clean air delivery rate, yielding a median of 0.023 m3 h−1 per cleaner, and a range over several orders of magnitude. To achieve the same removal as a typical building (which expects to achieve around 1 h−1 through air exchange), 10 to 1,000 plants per square metre would be needed. “This is not a point on horticulture: the constraint applies irrespective of the cost of the individual plant, since the number of plants needed is inversely related to per plant performance.”
The paper is thus comprised of the following four objectives. What is the clean-air equivalent, per square foot of floor space, provided by potted plants, in the same units used to rate mechanical cleaners? How much does that clean air cost on a levelled basis when compared to filtration and ventilation? What are the implicit health benefits per dollar spent in a high-exposure South Asian environment? But, under which circumstances, if any, would plant-based systems be economically viable? The contribution is threefold: a levelised cost of clean air (LCOA) metric making heterogeneous interventions directly comparable; the first break-even calculation identifying the per-plant performance necessary for phytoremediation to compete with filtration; and decision rules separating the justifiable, non-pollution control benefits of indoor vegetation (biophilic amenity and occupant wellbeing) from the indefensible benefits of pollution control
Analytical framework
This assessment happens in four stages: translation of phytoremediation evidence to a clean air delivery rate, scaling to a reference room to determine the plant inventory needed to deliver a ventilation-equivalent, translation of capital and operating costs to a levelised cost per cubic metre of clean air, and translation of the resulting exposure reduction to avoided DALYs. The steady-state indoor/outdoor ratio for a pollutant with negligible indoor source is:
Cin/Cout = Q / (Q + CADR + kdep·V)
where V is the volume of the room (m3). A plant assembly with CADR = Q cuts this ratio in half, but does not remove the pollutant. The inventories that are needed for that equivalence are:
N = Q / CADRp
The levelised cost of clean air annualises capital and operating costs per unit of delivered clean air:
LCOA = (Ccap·CRF(r,T) + Cop) / (CADR × 8760)
Where CRF is the capital recovery factor at the discount rate r over the life T. The capital component is not considered to be an amortised investment but is considered as an annual replacement charge for plants because the lifetime of plants is not long and is not guaranteed.
Health benefits are calculated in a marginal way without resorting to a counterfactual baseline. Avoided DALYs per year in a room that has n people is:
ΔDALY = n · ΔC · β · m0 · D
where β is fractional increase in adult mortality per µg m−3 PM2.5, m0 is the background annual adult mortality rate and D is the DALYs lost per premature death. The break-even per plant performance at which plants are equal to filtration costs is the annual cost per unit of clean air across technologies:
CADR*p = (annual cost per plant) / (cost per m3 h−1 of clean air from filtration)
-
Sifat, M. O. I., Sadik, W., Tahira, K. T., Mannan, S. I., Bonik, A., Ahnaf, M. A., Shohag, M., Islam, F., Sani, M. A. I., & Sunbeam, I. F. (2026). Can indoor plants reduce air pollution cost-effectively? An economic assessment of natural air purification. Contin. Acad. J. Integr. Res. Stud., 1(1), 17–27.
https://continentalacademicpublisher.com/journal/cajirs/can-indoor-plants-reduce-air-pollution-cost-effectively-an-economic-assessment-of-natural-air-purification